Joseph Newcomer, M.D.

Self-pay rates shown are averages across all procedures on file for this provider, sourced from Transparency in Coverage Act data. These are cash-pay prices — what you'd typically pay without using insurance. Actual rates may vary by procedure, location, and date of service.

Cost data sourced from insurer Transparency in Coverage Act filings. Costs shown are negotiated rates and may not reflect your actual out-of-pocket cost. Learn about our data

Overall, patient sentiment towards Dr. Joseph Newcomer, MD is mixed, with a 3.9-star rating based on 30 reviews. Approximately 70% of patients rated him five stars, indicating a significant portion of positive experiences. Many patients praised his attentiveness, ability to listen and answer questions, and the thorough explanations he provides regarding their conditions. Additionally, the friendliness of the staff and efficient appointment scheduling were frequently highlighted as positive aspects of the practice. However, there are notable criticisms as well. Some patients expressed dissatisfaction with the outcomes of their surgeries, particularly mentioning complications and misalignments that required further procedures. A few reviews pointed to a perceived lack of humility or acknowledgment of mistakes on Dr. Newcomer's part, which contributed to negative experiences. Specific issues included a knee replacement that was misaligned, leading to extensive follow-up surgeries and significant financial burdens for the patients involved. In summary, while many patients appreciate Dr. Newcomer's expertise and the supportive staff, potential patients should weigh the mixed reviews regarding surgical outcomes and the doctor's approach to patient concerns. Those considering an appointment may benefit from discussing any specific worries or expectations during their initial consultation.

Other orthopaedic surgery physician in IL