Logo
Profile last updated: April 2026How we source this data
TM
Provider Profile

Timothy Mcgrath, M.D.

Orthopaedic Surgery Physician

NPI: 1659371862

5

1 · US News Health

20

Years Exp.

Amherst

NY

Orthopaedic Surgery

Specialty

About

With 20 years of practice, Dr. McGrath has earned a perfect patient rating of 5.0 out of 5, reflecting his commitment to thorough patient care and effective communication. Patients commend him for his attentive listening and detailed explanations of medical conditions and treatment options, fostering a comfortable and supportive environment during visits. His estimated visit costs start at $320, making his high-quality care accessible.

Practicing Since

Jul 2005

Gender

Male

Experience

20 years

NY Medical License

#236504

Practice Type

Group Practice

NPI Number

1659371862

Additional Specialties

Orthopaedic Surgery
Avg. Self-Pay Rate

Self-pay rates shown are averages across all procedures on file for this provider, sourced from Transparency in Coverage Act data. These are cash-pay prices — what you'd typically pay without using insurance. Actual rates may vary by procedure, location, and date of service.

1ST INPATIENT CRITICAL CARE PR DAY AGE 28 DAYS/<

CPT: 99468professional

$914

INITIAL PED CRITICAL CARE 29 DAYS THRU 24 MONTHS

CPT: 99471professional

$791

INITIAL PED CRITICAL CARE 2 THRU 5 YEARS

CPT: 99475professional

$574

Cost data sourced from insurer Transparency in Coverage Act filings. Costs shown are negotiated rates and may not reflect your actual out-of-pocket cost. Learn about our data

Local Market

New York Low

$80

New York Typical

$133

New York High

$243

Across New York, a orthopaedic surgery physician visit ranges from $80 to $243 with a median of $133. This is 44% above the national median of $93. Based on 382 providers with published pricing data.

There are 2 orthopaedic surgery physicians in Amherst and 29 across New York on our platform.

See full orthopaedic surgery physician cost breakdown in New York
Patient Reviews

5

1 review

US News Health

Dr. Timothy McGrath, MD, an orthopedic surgeon with over 25 years of experience, has received overwhelmingly positive feedback from his patients, reflected in a high overall rating of 5 out of 5 based on 87 reviews. Patients frequently commend his thoroughness, attentive listening, and ability to clearly explain medical conditions and treatment options. Many appreciate that he takes the time to address their concerns and does not rush appointments, contributing to a comfortable and supportive patient experience. Despite the positive sentiment, a few criticisms have emerged, primarily regarding wait times for appointments, although specific instances were not frequently highlighted. Patients have also noted that while the majority of experiences were positive, there were a small number of less favorable reviews, indicating that not every patient had a perfect experience. Overall, Dr. McGrath is recognized as a trustworthy and skilled practitioner in his field, particularly in shoulder and upper arm surgery, making him a highly recommended choice for those seeking orthopedic care.

Location

Address

3925 SHERIDAN DR

Amherst, NY 14226

Phone

7162509999
Similar Doctors

Other orthopaedic surgery physician in NY

Momentary Lab sources provider data from the CMS NPI Registry and cost data from federal Transparency in Coverage files. Reviews aggregated from Healthgrades, Vitals, WebMD, and other public sources. Learn how we verify and update healthcare information.

This page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Cost estimates are based on publicly available negotiated rate data and may not reflect your actual out-of-pocket cost. Always consult with your healthcare provider and insurance company for accurate cost information and medical decisions.